Controversial Comic...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Controversial Comic Book Opinions

36 Posts
16 Users
1 Reactions
46 Views
John
 John
(@imported_admin)
Posts: 6994
Member Admin
Topic starter
 

The X Men deserve the persecution they get.

DC Doesn't know what the hell to do with Captain Marvel.

Reed Richards should be the foremost Marvel superhero.

Valkyrie should be Marvel's answer to Wonder Woman

Wonder Woman doesn't fit in out side of WW2

DC should have rebooted their whole entire line with number ones right after the first Crisis.

DC's One Earth is still the best idea.

Wolverine is not that great of a character AND shouldn't be on the Avengers.

Spider Man works best as a solo act.

Aunt May should die.

The X Men should be considered villains and beaten into submission by the Avengers

The Super Hero Registration Act was the right thing to do,

And Captain America should have used his clout and charisma to speak out against it, not to violently destroy half of NY in an insane fight.

Hulk became a villain in World War Hulk, and did more damage to NYC than Osama Bin Laden and should never be forgiven and not stopped being hunted.

The Watchmen movie was better than the comic!

 
Posted : September 14, 2010 2:53 am
rrtaylornz reacted
(@barney)
Posts: 33
Eminent Member
 

Great thread.

I agree that Aunt May should die. And stay dead. She was a plot device that ran her course.

I love Earth One, Two, and Three.

Spidey works bests solo--and hosting team-up books!

DC should get rid of the Shazams. They don't know what to do with them. Although I like Captain Marvel Jr.

I liked the Watchmen movie, for sure. There were parts that I thought worked better in the film than in the book, and parts that I thought worked better in print.

 
Posted : September 14, 2010 3:00 am
John
 John
(@imported_admin)
Posts: 6994
Member Admin
Topic starter
 

Adding on with Spider Man.

Aunt May was supposed to be one of Spider Man's weakness. He had a dependant person that he had to take care of. He had to get her medicine, he had to get her to the hospital... It added tension and excitment to the stories. Well I think they did everything they can with her, and the next logical step would be for him and Mary Jane to neuralise the Mephisto thing, remember they are married and have a baby.

AND the baby should have some sort of illness due to Peter's radiated blood and that would take over the weakness of dependent for him.

 
Posted : September 14, 2010 3:37 am
(@sunphoenix)
Posts: 779
Prominent Member
 

...Wolverine an AVENGER!?! This is why I stopped collecting comic some 7 years now - just about the time Legion goes back in time and kills Professor Xavier and causes the "Age of Apokcalypse". Not only were the comics too expensive and the titles I wanted to collect had their stories spread all over 10 or more titles I did not want to collect, but the writing got STUPID! Ben Parker?

I do not recognize the 'Heroes' and I use that term loosely here.. that are portrayed in mainstream comics. I pick up a title and thumb through it now and shake my head in disgust.

These are NOT the Heroes I grew up with!

Oh how we pine for the 80's and early 90's!

 
Posted : September 14, 2010 3:47 am
(@dominique)
Posts: 5970
Illustrious Member
 

I've never liked Wolverine and Spidey as Avengers. IMHO Spidey worked best in hsi solo book, or when he did his team ups.

Wolverine was far more interesting to me when he didn't have a back story.

The Avengers should be Marvel's greatest team, with a good mix of classic characters, and characters who can't keep up their own books.

There's to many damn "X" books.

DC's Big guns (Superman, Batman, and Wonder Woman) need to be back in the Justice League.

Quit killing Teen Titans.

Comics are to freaking expensive.

 
Posted : September 14, 2010 3:53 am
(@dracos)
Posts: 1670
Noble Member
 

3E3B3236315F0 wrote: AND the baby should have some sort of illness due to Peter's radiated blood? and that would take over the weakness of dependent for him.


DUDE
that's just cold 😮

Spidey's a great Avenger but part-time would be best.

Winter Soldiers a pinko punk pretender ad should be disintergrated along with half the other idiots at Marvel these days.

There should only be one Captain America. Steve Rogers, now and forever. Even if he did take the wrong "tactic" addressingthe Registration issue.

Aunt May's what 120 years old now? Hell she was a old as dirt when I was a kid over 30 years ago.

Wolverine an Avenger! Really. I mean please. (just thought it needed said again)

 
Posted : September 14, 2010 4:33 am
(@lionmane)
Posts: 1896
Famed Member
 

Are Spider-Man's kids mutants?

mw

 
Posted : September 14, 2010 6:08 am
(@davewoodrum)
Posts: 378
Reputable Member
 

Lobo was boring as a regular series comic book

Wolverine should change his hairstyle

Mr. Immortal is too cool of an idea to be confined to the slapstick of Great Lakes Avengers

Kang is a drag queen in mid form, what with those go go boots and that fuschia colored outfit and all....

Elastic Man is really just Mister Fantastic at a Devo concert....

The Invisible Woman's true identity is not Sue Richards, but rather Ann Coulter.

Quagmire was a really cool villain that never got enough credit... probably because he came from another one of them multiple Earths.

The Beyonder should have just remained a glowing point in the night sky... he looked a lot cooler.

Smokescreen, the character in Spiderman's anti-smoking comic book, should have became a full time hero... for corrupt Big Business.

Howard the Duck should have no place in the Marvel Universe... period. (Why not add Mickey Mouse why you are at it? )

There are way too many Spider Women/Spider Girls... and most of them aren't really that interesting.

Electra is boring.

 
Posted : September 14, 2010 6:05 pm
(@troy_wilson)
Posts: 65
Trusted Member
 

65607764766E6E6573746C010 wrote: Wolverine should change his hairstyle

This made me laugh! 🙂

 
Posted : September 14, 2010 7:08 pm
John
 John
(@imported_admin)
Posts: 6994
Member Admin
Topic starter
 

Howard the Duck rules.

Captain Marvel, Shazam, should be a Marvel comic and be in the Defenders.

The Inhumans rock!

Lobo and Deadpool should just go away. Forever.

Vampires and Zombies are played out.

DC's Frankenstein is a cool character.

Vic Sage is the only Question AND he should be like the Justice League Unlimited's version. I will make an exception for him ( see next opinion)

Unless your code name is Pheonix, which implies rebirth, when you die, you NEVER come back.

Keith Giffen is not a good writer, and as an artist he is a very good Ice Cream Man.

The worse Simon William's, Wonder Man, costume, the better!

Magneto is a villain.

The Punisher works best in Marvel Max, and there is no reason to make it a seperate continuity. He can go after the thugs that the Fantastic Four don't. The world is big enough for them both.

Frankencastle was a bad direction, it will be remembered in a few years just as the Angel Punisher was.

I didn't like the Bwa Haha JLA.

Galactus should have a purpose. He should be the first line of defense vs Lovecraftian creatures from Beyond. And after every battle he feeds. A planet is small price to pay to save the universe.

The Dark Avengers was a great series.

John Romita Jr, is just ok.

Steve Ditko was a great artist, but I think he developed mental problems and his art suffered for it.

Frank Millar is WAAAY overrated.

X Men SHMECKS men!

Without a Kryptonite Enema, Superman will ALWAYS beat Batman.

Superman will always lose to Captain Marvel.

The Thing is Marvel's best character.

I like John Byrne, still.

Moonknight is a solo agent. Maybe a team up once in a while, but no teams for him.

Xavier is creepy. He is morally questionable at best.

 
Posted : October 11, 2010 3:49 pm
(@davewoodrum)
Posts: 378
Reputable Member
 

Well, John, you know you set me up against you with that first line.... ;D
But I have to agree with you about zombies and vampires being played out... well, except that I sorta had this zombie adventure I was tinkering with awhile back and...

Oh, and Magneto is not a villain, he is a flamboyant fashion designer (who's alter ego is actually Tim Gunn), and he helped accessorize Kang which in turn gave Kang the courage that helped him reveal inner truths about himself that he had been hiding for years which in turn landed him an awesome contract for a great new show to be appearing soon on Logo...

See how this all works out in the end? Without Howard or Lobo?
(Okay, I'd admit, Lobo has been moonlighting as a security guard for the Logo executive offices)
- All of this I know for the truth, the voices in my head told me (the same ones that helped me write Citizen Report and the freebies, so look out!)

 
Posted : October 11, 2010 6:17 pm
(@zuggtmoy222)
Posts: 243
Reputable Member
 

Speaking about Aunt May....didn't she died and they reversed it with one of the lamest way possible? In any case, comic books have gotten ridiculous. Every character must have died at least once, if not twice and then came back, or revealed that they didn't really died. Just wait, it will be less than 5 years before the Wasp return from the dead. I wonder why superheroes go to funerals anymore.

 
Posted : October 12, 2010 12:41 am
(@mongoose)
Posts: 586
Honorable Member
 

Cloak and Dagger are two of the most under-rated, but best, street level superheroes around.

 
Posted : October 12, 2010 6:02 am
(@mongoose)
Posts: 586
Honorable Member
 

There should be a series that features the street level heroes / duos. Iron Fist / Power Man. Cloak and Dagger. Shang-Chi and Tarantula.

 
Posted : October 12, 2010 6:03 am
(@davewoodrum)
Posts: 378
Reputable Member
 

57584A4A594042541F1F1F2D0 wrote: Speaking about Aunt May....didn't she died and they reversed it with one of the lamest way possible? In any case, comic books have gotten ridiculous. Every character must have died at least once, if not twice and then came back, or revealed that they didn't really died. Just wait, it will be less than 5 years before the Wasp return from the dead. I wonder why superheroes go to funerals anymore.

Personally, although I'm not otherwise a soap opera fan by any means, I'm waiting for Stefano DiMera to show up and make everyone die and return, and get possessed, and carry his baby (the male heroes included 😀 ) at least five or six times... Stefano could turn out to be the new Doctor Doom.... and the Beyonder, all rolled into one... Again. ;D 😀 ;D 😀 ;D 😀

 
Posted : October 12, 2010 2:36 pm
Page 1 / 3